Student assault case highlights importance of recognising the Signal for Help

An 18-year-old American student allegedly subjected to sexual violence inside a food shop in central Florence was able to attract help by using the Signal for Help, a discreet hand gesture designed to indicate that someone may be in danger.

The incident happened during the night of 8-9 September 2026 near Borgo Pinti, a street on the eastern side of Florence’s historic centre, not far from the Santa Croce area.

A 31-year-old man who managed the business was arrested by the Carabinieri, one of Italy’s national police forces, on suspicion of sexual violence and unlawful detention. He remains in custody while the investigation continues. He is presumed innocent unless and until convicted.

What happened in Borgo Pinti

According to investigators’ reconstruction, the student had spent the evening with a friend at a pub in the Santa Croce area. Shortly before 2 a.m., the two stopped to get something to eat.

The 18-year-old entered a food shop near Borgo Pinti and asked to use the bathroom after ordering. Investigators allege that the manager locked the entrance and then sexually assaulted her.

The student managed to break away and reach the locked entrance. Unable to leave, she hit the shop window to attract attention and repeatedly made the Signal for Help with her hand.

A passer-by noticed her and understood that she was asking for assistance. The person called 112, the European emergency number, and a Carabinieri patrol was sent to the shop. Officers arrested the man.

On 11 September, a preliminary investigations judge in Florence ordered the suspect to remain in custody, finding that there was a risk of further violent offences. The man exercised his right not to answer questions during the hearing.

The investigation is continuing.

Shop ordered to close for 30 days

Florence police authorities subsequently ordered the business to close for 30 days under Article 100 of Italy’s public security laws.

The measure was issued by Florence’s questore, the senior provincial State Police authority, following a proposal by the Carabinieri. Authorities also issued the suspect with a formal preventive warning.

By 13 September, insults and death threats had also appeared on the shutters and walls outside the closed business.

What is the Signal for Help?

The Florence case has drawn attention to a gesture that can be particularly useful when a person in danger cannot safely speak or make an obvious request for assistance.

The Signal for Help was introduced by the Canadian Women’s Foundation in 2020, initially in response to concerns about gender-based violence during Covid-19 isolation. It has since spread internationally.

It can be made silently with one hand:

1. Hold up one hand with the palm facing the other person.
2. Fold the thumb into the palm.
3. Close the four fingers over the thumb, effectively trapping it inside the fist.

The movement, rather than simply a closed fist, is important.

It is intended to communicate discreetly that the person needs someone to check on them safely. It does not necessarily mean that the observer should immediately contact the police: the appropriate response depends on the circumstances and on what the person asking for help needs.

In an immediate emergency, however — as appeared to be the case in Florence — emergency services should be contacted.

What to do if you see the signal

Recognising the gesture is only part of its purpose. Knowing how to respond matters too.

The Canadian Women’s Foundation recommends finding a safe way to check on the person, listening to what they need and helping them contact appropriate services. If someone may be listening, questions that can be answered with yes or no can make communication safer.

The circumstances can also make the meaning clear. A person visibly trapped behind a locked door or window while making the gesture, for example, may require immediate emergency assistance.

In Tuscany, 112 is the single European emergency number for the Carabinieri, State Police, fire brigade and emergency medical services. Calls are free from landlines and mobile phones, and the service includes multilingual assistance — particularly relevant in a city such as Florence, with large numbers of international residents, students and visitors.

Help for victims of violence in Italy

Italy also operates 1522, the national anti-violence and anti-stalking helpline run by the government’s Department for Equal Opportunities.

The service is free and available 24 hours a day. Assistance is available in Italian, English, French, Spanish, Arabic and German, with additional languages available by appointment. People can also contact an operator through online chat or the 1522 app.

The service can provide information and direct people towards anti-violence centres, shelters and other support services.

In an immediate emergency in Florence or elsewhere in Tuscany: call 112.

For anti-violence and stalking support in Italy: call 1522 or use the 1522 online chat.

❤️ Support Florence Daily News

If you liked this article, please consider supporting Florence Daily News.

We are an independent news site, free from paywalls and intrusive ads, committed to providing clear and reliable reporting on Florence and Tuscany for everyone.

Your support — whether a one-time gift or a regular contribution — helps us stay independent and keep telling the stories that matter.

Donate securely via Stripe below.